Despite weeks of growing opposition from First Nations, municipal governments and environmental organizations, B.C.鈥檚 controversial Bill 15 is now law. A tie vote in the legislature on the evening of May 28 鈥� all 46 NDP MLAs supported the bill while 46 Conservative, Green and Independent MLAs voted against it 鈥� resulted in Speaker Raj Chouhan casting the deciding vote to pass the bill.
As debate on Bill 15 drew to a close, Premier David Eby鈥檚 office welcomed representatives from the Nisga鈥檃 Lisims Government to the legislature to witness the wind down. Nisga鈥檃 Lisims President Eva Clayton met with Eby to discuss Bill 15, the Infrastructure Projects Act, and Bill 14, the Renewable Energy Projects Streamlining Act, according to a letter from Clayton released by the premier鈥檚 office.
Clayton鈥檚 letter is one of few statements of support for Bill 15. Former NDP MLA Melanie Mark 鈥� B.C.鈥檚 first First Nations woman to serve as an MLA and cabinet minister 鈥� condemned the legislation for 鈥渂ypassing constitutionally protected and inherent First Nations/Indigenous Rights.鈥�
鈥淲hat is most astounding and disheartening is why David Eby and his cabinet are turning their backs on such a diverse group of leaders and allies like the First Nations Leadership Council, local governments, environmentalists and business leaders,鈥� Mark wrote in a statement posted on social media minutes after the bill became law.
鈥淎ll we are advocating for is more time.鈥�
For weeks, First Nations leaders warned that B.C. Premier David Eby鈥檚 push to pass Bill 15 is deeply damaging the province鈥檚 relationship with Indigenous Peoples.
鈥淭he BC NDP are wrong. Premier Eby is wrong. We are united in our call that they must immediately withdraw the bill,鈥� Don Tom, Chief of the Tsartlip First Nation and vice-president of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, said during a Monday press conference in Victoria.
鈥淭hey are willing to look past any sort of environmental assessment, they're willing to walk all over First Nations Rights, all under the guise of efficiency.鈥�
Bill 15, the Infrastructure Projects Act, grants the provincial government broad powers to expedite pretty much any major infrastructure project, whether publicly or privately owned. Eby and his government contend those powers are needed to ramp up the delivery of community infrastructure 鈥� such as hospitals, schools, community centres and seniors鈥� homes 鈥� and to seize the economic opportunity in the growing global demand for low-carbon electricity. Eby has argued the push for clean energy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel use requires the rapid development of critical minerals mines, ports and other trade corridors.
Critics say the government is using buzz about a low-carbon future and U.S. President Donald Trump鈥檚 threats to Canada鈥檚 economy and sovereignty to centralize power and deprioritize environmental considerations and Indigenous Rights.
B.C. doesn鈥檛 need Bill 15 to pursue critical minerals: Eby
As Tom and other First Nations leaders were in Victoria calling for Bill 15 to be scrapped, Eby was in Vancouver, announcing his government鈥檚 intent to bring billions of dollars of mining investment to northwest B.C. The press conference featured few details as to when and how the province plans to achieve that goal 鈥� or even what, exactly, it hopes to achieve 鈥� but Eby emphasized mining projects will be developed with the support of First Nations on whose territories the sought-after metals and minerals are located.
He also made clear the government does not need the powers Bill 15 would provide to make its mining dream a reality.
鈥淭here is no connection between Bill 15 and today's announcement,鈥� Eby told reporters.
He said the government intends to work together with First Nations and mining companies to find mutually agreeable ways to extract critical minerals and protect traditional territories in northwest B.C.
Eby did acknowledge that 鈥渋n theory鈥� his government could use Bill 15鈥檚 powers to fast-track mining projects in northwest B.C. 鈥� something he said would only happen after securing an agreement with First Nations.
鈥淭hat's quite speculative,鈥� he said.
If the B.C. government doesn鈥檛 need Bill 15 to realize its critical minerals goals or to turn the province into an electricity powerhouse 鈥� something another new law empowers the government to do 鈥� it鈥檚 hard to see why it pushed so hard to pass the controversial legislation; especially as it draws condemnation from First Nations, local governments, environmental organizations and opposition parties.
Conservative Party Leader John Rustad 鈥� who campaigned on repealing the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act during the 2024 election 鈥� condemned Eby鈥檚 response to concerns voiced by First Nations.
鈥淚 find it quite offensive that Mr. Eby would respond to First Nation(s) leaders saying, 鈥楯ust trust us,鈥� 鈥� Rustad told reporters. 鈥淗e has done nothing to earn that trust from the people of British Columbia.鈥�
Eby鈥檚 assurances about his government鈥檚 intentions for Bill 15 do appear to be too little, too late for some.
鈥淗ow can we believe a premier who told us during the [election] campaign that he would respect First Nations Rights and who then ignored them and turned around and showed us his back when it was time to implement the First Nations Rights?鈥� Hugh Braker, a member of the First Nations Summit鈥檚 political executive, asked at the Victoria press conference.
鈥淭he NDP government has purposefully chosen to paint themselves with a brush filled with the paint of hypocrisy,鈥� he added. 鈥淎ll the promises they made during the campaign last fall have gone out the window. They say, 鈥楧amn the environment, full speed ahead.鈥� 鈥�
First Nations concerns must be addressed, supporters say
The backlash to Bill 15 has been building steadily since it was introduced in the legislature on May 1. The bill makes changes that 鈥渞educe delays for urgently needed projects,鈥� according to the provincial government press release, which included supportive quotes from seven leaders of municipal governments, public service agencies, post-secondary institutions and corporations.
New Westminster Mayor Patrick Johnstone was one of the people quoted in the press release. He told The Narwhal he was asked by Infrastructure Minister Bowinn Ma to endorse the bill after the pair spoke about the difficulty of building schools in New Westminster.
鈥淚 expected that the focus on accelerating those approval processes on the provincial side would be welcomed by the Union of BC Municipalities,鈥� Johnstone said. 鈥淓very time that we approve new housing in my community, the only question people ask me is, 鈥榃here are the schools? Where are the hospitals?鈥� 鈥�
While he supports the parts of the bill that apply to public sector projects, Johnstone said it has become evident the provincial government has work to do to address the criticisms raised by Indigenous leaders. 鈥淚 do hear that concern from First Nations and that is something for the government to address. For a government who has expressed, repeatedly, its commitment to the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, I think that needs to be an important part of this legislation.鈥�
Colleen Giroux-Schmidt, vice-president of Innergex, was also quoted in the Bill 15 press release. The company is partnering with First Nations on three of the wind power projects selected by the province to be exempted from environmental assessments and approved under a new process to be developed by the BC Energy Regulator.
She said she believes B.C.鈥檚 project permitting and approvals processes could use some streamlining but that consultation and communication with First Nations, local governments and communities impacted by developments are key.
鈥淲hat we鈥檝e seen is that time doesn't always equal rigour and the [permitting] process doesn't always lead us to the best options,鈥� she said in an interview. 鈥淲hat does is early and ongoing consultation and engagement with the Indigenous nations whose territory the project is in or who are co-proponents and partners in the project.鈥�
Actions, not words, demanded on B.C.鈥檚 Bill 15
In the weeks before Bill 15鈥檚 passage, many First Nations leaders criticized the B.C. government鈥檚 handling of the bill, while emphasizing that they are not necessarily opposed to development.
鈥淲e get that there are some projects that perhaps will get the green light and will get the blessing for development and certainly we're not against the development of hospitals and schools,鈥� Terry Teegee, regional Chief of the B.C. Assembly of First Nations, said in a May 21 press conference. 鈥淗owever, First Nations and other local governments need more consultation and discussions in terms of how decisions are made within our traditional territories and how this legislation is overreaching.鈥�
First Nations Leadership Council member Robert Phillips called the introduction of Bill 15 鈥渁n unfortunate yet avoidable moment鈥� in B.C.鈥檚 history.
鈥淭he province of B.C. has chosen to abandon decades of ... intensive, collective work to build principled pathways and tools to advance reconciliation for the benefit of not only First Nations, but all British Columbians,鈥� Phillips told reporters on May 21.
Eby has acknowledged his government鈥檚 consultations with First Nations about Bill 15 fell short of its obligations under B.C.鈥檚 Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. Critics say that lack of consultation means the legislation needs to be withdrawn, rewritten and reintroduced when the legislature resumes in the fall.
However, the premier insists the lack of advance consultation on Bill 15 can be remedied when the regulations to put meat on the bones of the bill are developed 鈥� a process that could begin soon. His entreaties have left many First Nations leaders unconvinced.
鈥淭he era of trust between Premier Eby and First Nations chiefs is over,鈥� Tsartlip Chief Tom told reporters on Monday. 鈥淭he era of trust is over and now it's based on results. And based on results, he has shown that we are not a partner here in B.C. 鈥� that he makes the decisions unilaterally, whether it be environmental assessments or the Declaration Act.鈥�
Expect lawsuits, First Nations leaders warn
Strident criticism notwithstanding, Eby made clear he sees Bill 15鈥檚 passage as an inflection point for the province.
鈥淓very NDP MLA understands that this is a fork in the road, and that is a fork in the road between court and litigation and fighting and between co-operation and shared prosperity,鈥� he told reporters Monday.
First Nations leaders have stated repeatedly that they intend to challenge the bill in court.
At one swipe of the pen, the premier can put all of this off to the fall, and that's what we're calling for 鈥� to kill the bill,鈥� Phillips, of the First Nations Leadership Council, said.
Phillips and other First Nations leaders demanded the B.C. government withdraw Bill 15 and reintroduce a new bill that addresses the identified concerns when the legislature resumes in the fall.
鈥淚f this isn't done, then we're going to see conflict, we're going to see court cases, we're going to see protests,鈥� Phillips said. 鈥淭his amount of disrespect that's happened with the premier moving forward like this, it's unbelievable.鈥�
This story is available for use by Canadian Press clients through an agreement with The Narwhal. It was originally published in The Narwhal, a non-profit online magazine that publishes in-depth journalism about the natural world in Canada. Sign up for weekly updates at thenarwhal.ca/newsletter.
Shannon Waters, The Narwhal
